insanejournal.com
Very quiet, one person who looks like fandom-oriented running it with volunteers helping. 100 icons on free status, 300 with a paid account (which works out to be a little cheaper than lj's paid services). I've created this journal, Derek's and carpentersbride over there, and it looks like it'll be a lot less likely to pull stunts like GJ such as dropping your icons unexpectedly, or deleting posts with 'questionable' content (which apparently has been happening over there at GJ as well, if some posts are to be believed).